Read more notes

← All journals
September 14, 2026

Not worth saying who he is

Two riders stop Balian in the desert. One of them points at his companion and says the horse Balian is riding is his. Balian asks how that could be, and says the horse came to him out of the sea. The man he pointed at calls Balian a liar and says he will fight him for it. Balian answers that he has no desire to fight. Then give up the horse, the man says. He will not, and after that there is nothing left but the fight. The man who issued the challenge dies.

The film waits an hour before correcting the arithmetic. The man who died was the servant. The calm one, who then walked Balian to Jerusalem, was the nobleman — a commander in Saladin’s army. He never lied. It is Balian who decides he has killed the man’s master, and who says aloud that he has taken it well; the commander answers only that it was the end of that man’s time, as God wills it, and tells him to finish. He had said the horse was his — a sentence that could mean either of them — and he let the rest stand.

What is worth stopping on is not the twist but the decision inside it. Announcing his rank in that moment buys him nothing. It could get him killed by a stranger who now has a reason to fear him, or held for ransom, or dragged into avenging a servant’s stupidity. Silence keeps every option open; speaking closes them. He also has to sit there being taken for a servant by a man beneath him in rank and find it not worth the trouble to correct. Most people’s pride will not survive that. His servant’s did not, which is why the servant is dead.

The two of them are the same lesson from opposite ends. One had to be seen as what he was, in front of a single witness. The other could be mistaken for nothing and ride out of the desert with a full measure of the Frank who spared him, having given away none of himself.

I watched this in the same weeks a student asked me how to build a company that nobody knows he owns. He has a character in mind from a television series — the recluse who builds the system and then works inside his own company as an ordinary employee. The instinct is not bad. What is worth separating is which kind of not-saying he is actually after, because they look identical from outside.

One is operational. You stay quiet because concealment is an asset you intend to spend later, and the reveal is the point. That is still oriented to an audience, just a deferred one. The other has no reveal in it. The commander in the desert expected never to see Balian again. Nothing was being set up.

For a founder the distinction has a cost attached, and it is not a moral one. Secrecy is an extremely effective way of never finding out you are wrong. If nobody sees the thing, nobody can tell you it does not work, and you can spend a year building something that failed in the first month. Secrecy also protects the wrong asset. The concept is cheap. What is worth taking is who pays, at what price, through which channel — and none of that is protected by not telling people your idea. It is protected by shipping before someone with more capital decides the market is real.

So the question I would put to him is the one the desert scene puts. Could you be underestimated by someone you will never meet again, with no reveal ever coming, and be at peace with it? If yes, the discipline is his. If no, the silence is still about being seen, and a business is a poor place to work that out.